New York’s dictatorial Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo could have met his match. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn is asking the U.S. Supreme Courtroom to strike down Cuomo’s Oct. 6 government order shutting down homes of worship in areas of Brooklyn and Queens, whereas permitting “important” companies, like pet shops, groceries and big-box shops to remain open.
Cuomo insists his restrictions are wanted to battle the unfold of COVID-19. The diocese says Cuomo is making a worth judgment that going to a Goal retailer is “important” however taking communion is not. Reality is, for religious communicants who’re already struggling social isolation in the course of the pandemic, discovering the church doorways closed could be soul-crushing.
Earlier than Cuomo’s government order, church buildings have been already following security precautions together with roping off each different pew, requiring masks and urging social distancing. The chief order disregarded that and capped attendance at 10 folks — even for big church buildings with a capability of 1,200. Sounds arbitrary. The place’s the science right here?
CUOMO ADMIN IN SUPREME COURT BRIEF ARGUES NY VIRUS RULES MORE LENIENT TO CHURCHES THAN SECULAR EVENTS
In a decrease courtroom listening to, Bryon Backenson, an official within the New York state Well being Division, testified that the chief orders focusing on the homes of worship “have been made within the governor’s workplace,” and never by the Well being Division or its epidemiologists.
As well as, two Orthodox Jewish teams filed an analogous enchantment to the Supreme Courtroom final week in search of aid, arguing that Cuomo “made it unimaginable” for the teams to “train their spiritual religion.”
Cuomo has clashed repeatedly with sure Jewish teams holding giant gatherings in defiance of social distancing. However the Orthodox teams that appealed to the Supreme Courtroom argue that they haven’t “violated any public well being or security guidelines.” They’re victims of the governor’s “guilt by spiritual affiliation.”
Cuomo admits his method is sort of a “hatchet. It is simply very blunt.” Blunt and unfair.
The Jewish and Catholic teams are asking the justices to attract a line between the federal government’s emergency powers throughout a pandemic and the basic rights assured tin the Structure. Even a pandemic would not justify obliterating the First Modification’s assured proper enabling us to observe faith with out authorities interference.
Count on the justices to take this case and reverse the courtroom’s earlier, extreme deference to the emergency well being powers of governors like California Democrat Gavin Newsom.
Final Could, after Newsom had restricted church attendance to 25% of constructing capability, the South Bay United Pentecostal Church sued. Newsom’s rule additionally utilized to theatres however to not groceries, banks, laundromats and different companies. But the Supreme Courtroom justices voted 5- four to defer to the governor, with Chief Justice John Roberts becoming a member of the liberal wing.
It is potential that Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who reads the Structure’s textual content actually, will probably be sympathetic. Nowhere does the Structure say that in occasions of pandemics, the Invoice of Rights is suspended.
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR OPINION NEWSLETTER
The sheer size of the pandemic can be prone to make a distinction within the Supreme Courtroom’s method. The courtroom seems poised to step in towards the repeated assaults on spiritual freedom.
“It pains me to say this,” Justice Samuel Alito noticed in a speech to the Federalist Society lately, “however in sure quarters, spiritual liberty is quick changing into a disfavored proper.” It’s definitely disfavored by Cuomo and his friends within the Hollywood elite.
Finally, there’s extra at stake even than spiritual freedom. As Alito warned, the type of lawmaking by government fiat that’s occurring in states like New York “has resulted in beforehand unimaginable restrictions on particular person liberty.”
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Individuals have to demand that their legislators restrict the emergency well being powers being wielded by governors. State lawmakers have to restrict the period and scope of those powers. Some states are already doing so, together with Michigan and Wisconsin. Sadly, in a state dominated by one social gathering, like New York, there isn’t a will to buck the governor.
The losers are most people. Think about if New York legislators have been requested to vote on shutting down church buildings. They would not dare. But Cuomo does it with impunity, simply the way in which he is shutting down eating places and different companies folks have spent their lives constructing. The final word treatment is to return to democratic authorities and finish the reign of those petty tyrants.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE FROM BETSY MCCAUGHEY