Hong Kong has fined a journalist for ticking a field. That exhibits the town’s media freedoms are in jeopardy


In essence, Choy was prosecuted for ticking a field: She had used a authorities registry to hint license plates related to a mob that had attacked pro-democracy protesters in a subway station in 2019.

Previously, journalists had been in a position to specify “media” on the shape to clarify why they have been looking out the database. However in 2019 the shape modified, so Choy ticked “different visitors and transport associated issues.”

That was a criminal offense. The 37-year-old was accused of violating Hong Kong’s Highway Visitors Ordinance by making a false declaration and fined 6,000 Hong Kong ($770).

To many onlookers, nevertheless, Choy’s case wasn’t about misused packing containers. It was an assault on journalism.

Though freedom of speech and the press are enshrined in Hong Kong’s mini-constitution, the Primary Regulation, the media’s independence and talent to report has come beneath risk in recent times. The controversial nationwide safety legislation, a sweeping piece of laws handed final yr, urges the federal government to additional regulate media and the web.

Thugs smash Epoch Occasions’ printing press in Hong Kong in April 2021. Credit score: Epoch Occasions

Previously month alone, there have been a slew of assaults on press freedom: A Chinese language state-run paper in Hong Kong known as for an embattled pro-democracy paper to close; the town’s police chief proposed an anti-fake information legislation; and thugs accused of being linked to the Chinese language Communist Get together smashed the printing press of an impartial newspaper.

Choy’s case is emblematic of the continually shifting guidelines within the metropolis — the brand new actuality that actions deemed affordable in the future may result in prosecution the following.

Ticking a field

On a summer time evening in July 2019, a mob of about 70 males in white shirts stormed a Hong Kong subway station and commenced to beat commuters and protesters with iron bars and bamboo sticks.

Movies from the evening present commuters screaming in subway vehicles in Yuen Lengthy station, close to the border with mainland China. The boys appeared to focus on these wearing black coming back from pro-democracy demonstrations in one other a part of Hong Kong.

As individuals frantically known as for assist, authorities acquired greater than 24,000 calls in three-and-a-half hours — nicely over the typical every day quantity, officers later instructed the town’s legislative physique.
Nevertheless it took 39 minutes for the riot police to reach. By then, a lot of the white-clad mob had left, in line with an Unbiased Police Complaints Council report.

Later, the police stated officers have been busy with protests on Hong Kong island, some 30 kilometers (19 miles) away. Not one of the white-clad males was arrested that evening, though dozens have been arrested subsequently.

To the pro-democracy camp, this was a turning level. Tensions have been already hovering after greater than a month of main protests, however the horrific scenes coupled with the police’s gradual response solely added to a deterioration of belief in officers. Many believed members of the mob — suspected by members of the general public to be linked to crime gangs — have been colluding with the authorities, though the police denied it.

It was that pivotal occasion that public broadcaster Radio Tv Hong Kong (RTHK) and freelance producer Choy wished to analyze.

The outlet obtained CCTV footage from across the subway station that evening which captured autos carrying males in white shirts. So Choy used what had lengthy been a typical journalistic methodology: She searched the automobile registration database to see who owned them.

A number of of the license plates, Choy discovered, have been linked to village representatives, or native leaders.

Bao Choy arrives at Fanling Magistrates' Court for a hearing.
Yuen Lengthy, an space nearer to mainland China than Hong Kong’s iconic Victoria Harbor, has allegedly lengthy been dwelling to so-called triad members, who researchers say have been used as “thugs for rent” in mainland China. Native Hong Kong officers have even confronted allegations of working with the felony gangs.

RTHK’s documentary provided extra proof that when the white-clad mob attacked individuals in Yuen Lengthy’s prepare station, that they had some official assist.

A violation or a seek for reality?

After RTHK’s 23-minute documentary, “Hong Kong Connection: 721 Who Owns the Reality,” was launched final yr, it received reward and awards, together with one final Wednesday from the Hong Kong Journalists Affiliation (HKJA).

However on November three, 2020, Choy was arrested on suspicion of violating the Highway Visitors Ordinance.

The federal government stated Choy’s case was the results of a grievance. At her trial, the choose dominated that automobile homeowners anticipated privateness once they submitted their info to the Transport Division, and located her responsible of violating the ordinance, a cost carrying as much as six months in jail.
Radio Television Hong Kong producer Bao Choy arrives at the West Kowloon Courts building in Hong Kong on April 22, 2021.

Choy is believed to be the primary journalist convicted of violating the ordinance, and the primary individual sentenced in reference to the Yuen Lengthy assaults, in line with her lawyer, Jonathan Man. Final week, police confirmed they arrested a reporter from state-owned pro-Beijing outlet Ta Kung Pao over the identical cost in February.

After the decision, Choy’s eyes grew pink as she stood, surrounded by cheering supporters and media, exterior a court docket in West Kowloon the place many pro-democracy activists have been prosecuted over the previous yr.

“I consider that investigative journalism is just not a criminal offense,” she stated. “My journalistic values won’t be affected by this case.”

Chris Yeung, the chair of the HKJA, known as the decision a “darkish day” for Hong Kong journalism.

“Press freedom in Hong Kong is dying,” he stated. “It is a advantageous for all journalists.”

To Lokman Tsui, an assistant professor at Chinese language College Hong Kong’s college of journalism and communication, stated the case is an indication the federal government is transferring the purpose posts.

Earlier than the choice to specify media was faraway from the kinds in 2019, journalist requests have been frequent — in some years, they made up a quarter of all functions. In an announcement to CNN Enterprise, Hong Kong Transport Division stated the 2019 revision was to “higher elaborate the needs for the avoidance of bewilderment” and famous that even earlier than the change, the information obtained by the request was solely meant for use for actions associated to visitors and transport issues.

However the case set a precedent that trying up a license plate for journalistic causes is now not authorized — one other blow for freedom of knowledge, Tsui stated.

Tsui stated it additionally seems to indicate that authorities are ready to go after journalists who dig up issues that made them look dangerous. “It is arduous to not see this as an assault on reality,” he added.

In an announcement to CNN Enterprise, the Hong Kong authorities stated any arrest had “nothing to do with the political stance, background or occupation” of the individual involved.

Different blows

For years, Hong Kong was dwelling to a vigorous media panorama with publications spanning the political spectrum. However the metropolis’s media freedoms have slowly diminished in recent times as mainland China’s affect over the previous British territory grows.

“Everybody in Hong Kong is self censoring,” stated Tsui stated. “Within the final couple of years, there was a sustained assault — not simply on press freedom, however on rights usually.”

A number of occasions in 2018, for instance, had a very chilling impact on the media atmosphere.

That yr, the Monetary Occasions’ Asia editor Victor Mallet‘s utility for a routine extension of his Hong Kong work allow was denied months after he hosted a chat by a pro-independence activist on the Overseas Correspondent’s Membership. Distinguished English-language paper South China Morning Publish was criticized for operating an interview with a Hong Kong writer who was detained within the mainland. The interview had been organized by China’s public safety ministry, elevating issues in regards to the newspaper’s choice to run what some noticed as a coerced interview. Individually, a cultural establishment all of the sudden canceled a chat with exiled Chinese language author Ma Jian. The venue stated on the time it didn’t wish to turn into “a platform to advertise the political pursuits of any particular person.”

Police raid Apple Day by day’s places of work in Hong Kong in August 2020. Credit score: Apple Day by day

And media freedom advocates argue that the panorama has solely gotten extra hostile since final yr’s nationwide safety legislation got here into impact.

Whereas Carrie Lam, the town’s chief, stated after that legislation was handed that Hong Kong individuals ought to nonetheless be capable of take pleasure in freedom of speech and press, the brand new rule was later used to carry fees towards media mogul Jimmy Lai, the founding father of the pro-democracy tabloid Apple Day by day. As police raided his newspaper’s places of work, they charged him with organizing an unauthorized protest and colluding with overseas forces.

The nationwide security-related fees towards Lai are nonetheless pending, and the laws has not but been used towards reporters. However Tsui, from Chinese language College Hong Kong, stated that would change sooner or later.

In an announcement to CNN Enterprise on Tuesday, the Hong Kong authorities stated it’s “firmly dedicated to defending and respecting the liberty of the press, which is a basic proper assured by the Primary Regulation.”

When requested whether or not it was doubtless journalists can be prosecuted beneath the nationwide safety legislation sooner or later, the federal government stated that “law-abiding individuals won’t unwittingly violate the legislation.”

Stress on journalists has continued to mount this yr. In February, for instance, Xia Baolong, the director of China’s Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Workplace, known as for Hong Kong’s media to be run by “patriots.”

Members of the media are feeling the squeeze, too. Final yr, the HKJA discovered a 3rd of journalists surveyed felt pressured by their seniors to drop or cut back reporting on Hong Kong independence. And Keith B. Richburg, director of the Journalism and Media Research Heart on the College of Hong Kong and the pinnacle of the town’s Overseas Correspondents Membership, stated journalists had famous some sources did not wish to speak anymore.

A latest rating of worldwide press freedoms signifies that the atmosphere in Hong Kong has modified. The worldwide watchdog Reporters With out Borders — which qualifies such freedoms based mostly on information on abuse and acts of violence towards journalists together with a questionnaire to consultants — ranked Hong Kong 80 out of 180 international locations for press freedom, down from 18 out of 138 in 2002.

Pressures on RTHK

Maybe no publication in Hong Kong has extra soul looking out to do than public broadcaster RTHK relating to navigating the brand new panorama. Over the previous 12 months, the station — which started broadcasting in 1928, when the town was beneath British rule — has axed episodes of present affairs exhibits, stopped broadcasting BBC World information packages, and investigated one its most profitable reporters who grew to become recognized for her probing questions of officers.
Hong Kong public broadcaster Radio Television Hong Kong (RTHK) staffers wear masks depicting the journalist Nabela Qoser during a silent protest against the management's treatment of her outside Broadcasting House on January 28, 2021 in Hong Kong.
In February, the Hong Kong authorities introduced the broadcaster’s director Leung Ka-wing can be stepping down early, to get replaced by Patrick Li, a civil servant with none media expertise — prompting RTHK’s program employees union to say the station had misplaced its editorial independence.
As he started in his new job in March, Li instructed reporters there was no “freedom with out restraint.” And on Tuesday, RTHK introduced a brand new slot for chief govt Lam who will now seem on the channel 4 occasions per week to debate Beijing’s overhaul of Hong Kong’s electoral system.

In an emailed assertion to CNN Enterprise, RTHK stated it doesn’t touch upon particular person court docket instances or staffing points. The broadcaster stated that it suspended the BBC World Service after the Nationwide Radio and Tv Administration introduced that BBC World Information was not allowed to proceed inside Chinese language territory. Its packages should abide by the constitution, the producers’ tips and the legal guidelines of Hong Kong, the broadcaster added. “As stipulated within the Constitution, RTHK is editorially impartial.”

As for Choy, the RTHK reporter: When requested by the media Tuesday whether or not Choy’s verdict undermined investigative journalism, Lam stated no one is above the legislation.

“If the legislation right now would not permit you to do sure issues — and although we respect freedom of speech and I acknowledge your career — you can not do it. We have to stability the pursuits of various events.”

Beijing’s financial affect

There are issues that mainland China’s elevated financial affect on Hong Kong may exert strain on media retailers within the metropolis.

Clement So, a Chinese language College of Hong Kong professor who research Hong Kong’s media panorama, stated up to now decade, a rising variety of media organizations had mainland Chinese language funding, one thing he believed may result in self-censorship.

After distinguished English-language paper the South China Morning Publish (SCMP) was purchased by Chinese language tech large Alibaba in 2015, for instance, there was concern the paper’s editorial freedom can be compromised. Critics have hyper-analyzed the publication for indicators of Beijing’s affect — however it has continued to report on matters that Chinese language state media do not contact, such because the Hong Kong protests and human rights abuses in Xinjiang.

Employees work in the newsroom of the South China Morning Post (SCMP) in Hong Kong, on June 5, 2020.
Final month Bloomberg and Wall Road Journal reported the Chinese language authorities wished the Alibaba group to shed a few of its media property — doubtlessly together with SCMP — attributable to its outsize affect over public opinion, after its founder Jack Ma fell from grace for publicly criticizing Chinese language monetary regulators. If Beijing now not authorised of Ma, one in all China’s digital darlings and international success tales, proudly owning the newspaper, it raised questions over who may be deemed an applicable purchaser.

An SCMP journalist — who requested to not be named — stated they and others within the newsroom felt an “on the spot panic,” fearing the customer could possibly be a state-owned entity or pro-Beijing firm.

In an inner e-mail seen by CNN Enterprise, nevertheless, SCMP chief govt Gary Liu stated Alibaba’s dedication to SCMP “stays unchanged,” and the corporate “won’t be responding publicly to those unsubstantiated rumors.” CNN Enterprise has reached out to Alibaba for remark.

The experiences additionally offered a silver lining, although. To the worker, the widespread concern over SCMP’s future confirmed the paper’s worth.

“No less than we’re having conversations now about why the SCMP is definitely taking part in fairly an vital position and what that may imply if it was misplaced,” the SCMP journalist stated.

Comply with the cash

To journalist Ronson Chan, vice-chairman of the HKJA, all this factors to an unmistakable conclusion: there’s now a potential hazard in being a journalist in Hong Kong.

“When you ask my coronary heart, in fact, I do know being a journalist, particularly working for a non-Beijing managed media, will need to have some warning or potential hazard,” stated Chan, who has labored throughout 11 media retailers, together with at non-profit investigative information company FactWire, the place he labored with Choy.

Now an editor at non-profit pro-democracy information web site Stand Information, he says he would not be shocked if he was arrested.

A part of the issue is a basic disagreement over the aim of reports. Whereas Western journalism idea sees worth in objectivity and holding authority to account, Chinese language leaders see it has a “software of political propaganda,” he stated.

Chan believes China’s historical past of cracking down on dissidents and journalists tells him he ought to depart the town, earlier than he’s prosecuted. That is one thing he has mentioned together with his spouse. “I do not know if it can turn into an proof in my prosecution speaking to you right now,” he stated.

It would not be the primary time: interviews Apple Day by day’s Lai gave to worldwide media have been cited as proof in his nationwide safety legislation instances.

However ultimately, Chan needs to proceed reporting in his metropolis.

“Hong Kong is our dwelling,” stated Chan. “If we left, the Hong Kong individuals haven’t any information to learn.”

— CNN’s Eric Cheung contributed reporting from Hong Kong.

Supply hyperlink


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here